Hamlet ~ Act IV Scene II
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern turn up to question Hamlet about the body of Polonius. Hamlet again speaks very insightful nonsense to them, which they do not appear to understand. Finally he agrees to be taken to the king.
 |
| Gather Ye Rosebuds, or Ophelia (1908) John William Waterhouse source Wikiart |
Thoughts:
I wonder ...... are Rosencrantz and Guildenstern dense? They are carrying out Claudius' orders without question, and the copious insults that Hamlet flings at them, seem to pass right over their heads.
What exactly did Hamlet mean when he said "The body is with the king, but the king is not with the body ..." Is this a reference to his father's murder, in that his dead body the responsibility of Claudius, but Claudius is not physically with it? Or what he hinting that Claudius was actually to blame for the death of Polonius, even though he wasn't physically with the body?
Hamlet Read-Along Posts
You could wrap yourself up in a Gordian knot with those questions! Technically R&G should be loyal to their leader, which is Claudius. Oh, but wait a minute! Should he be the leader, or should Hamlet actually have inherited the title from his father? In that case, they should be loyal to Hamlet. Then you get into the morality of it ........ Claudius (it appears) committed a crime, so they should be loyal to Hamlet. And there's the weaker argument (IMO) that Hamlet is their friend, so their loyalty should be with him. This conundrum reminds me very much of Sophocles' Antigone, don't you think? Loyalty to state or loyalty to your conscience .....?
ReplyDeleteShakespeare is so brilliant at tying up his audience in prospective moral, political and emotion knots, which all conflict with each other. I guess that's why he's The Master!